Skip to main content.

Evidence lodged by Submitters

Logo of the Board of Inquiry.

Last updated: 13 April 2010

A list of the submitters who have confirmed their wish to be heard by the Board of Inquiry is available.

The list of witnesses for submitters to be cross-examined (PDF, 244) is available.

Legal submissions and evidence lodged by submitters are available below.

Legal submissions presented

Submission
number
Submitter Legal submissions presented Date presented
1041 Mighty River Power Ltd Ian Cowper (PDF, 269  KB) 7 July 2008
1200 Waikato District Council Lachlan Muldowney (PDF, 2 MB) 7 July 2008
1019 Meridian Energy Ltd Nicky McIndoe (PDF, 1 MB) 7 July 2008
0919
0984
Waipa District Council David Kirkpatrick (PDF, 4 MB) 8 July 2008
1113 Matamata-Piako District Council Phil Lang (PDF, 2 MB) 17 & 18 July 2008
1070 Glencoal Energy Ltd & The Stirlings Suzanne Janissen (PDF, 2 MB) 21 July 2008
1046 New Era Energy (South Waikato Inc) Joan Forret (PDF, 3 MB) 21 July 2008
0837 Orini Downs Station Farm Ltd Joan Forret (PDF, 2 MB) 22 July 2008
1025 Phillip & Delwyn Dombroski Jamie Bright (PDF, 2 MB) 25 July 2008

1065

Auckland Regional Council

John Burns (PDF, 608 KB)

8 September 2008

0748

Hunua & Paparimu Valley Ratepayers Association Inc.

Douglas Allan (PDF, 3 MB)

11 September 2008

1244

Underground in Manukau

David Kirkpatrick (PDF, 675 KB)

12 September 2008

0799

South Waikato District Council

Kevin Parker (PDF, 803  KB)

6 October 2008

0558 & 1014

Carter Holt Harvey Ltd & Hancock Forest Management (NZ) Ltd

Ralph Simpson (PDF, 1 MB)

7 October 2008

0852

Drummond Dairy Ltd & Scenic Dairy Ltd

Joan Forret (PDF, 1 MB)

7 October 2008

Evidence received

Submission number Submitter Witness evidence lodged Exhibits and supporting documents lodged

0549

Ardmore Airfield Tenants & Users Committee

Allan McCreadie (PDF, 150 KB)

Updated evidence

AS/NZS Risk Management Standard
1065 Auckland Regional Council

Sally Peake (PDF, 668 KB)

Matthew Richards (PDF, 219 KB)
 

0826

Auld, Mark & Nicky

Nicky & Mark Auld (PDF, 32 KB)

 

1085

Bennet, Dr Laura

Dr Laura Bennet (PDF, 70 KB)

 

0730

Bilby, Lorraine J & Stewart Ross C

Lorraine Bilby (PDF, 17 KB)

 

0406

Brennan, Catherine

Geoff Copstick and Catherine Brennan (PDF, 1010 KB)

Updated evidence

Appendices included with Evidence
0842 Camperdown Holdings Ltd Jonathan Maplesden (PDF, 416 KB)  

0405

Copstick, Geoff

Geoff Copstick and Catherine Brennan (PDF, 1310 KB)

Updated evidence

Appendices included with Evidence

0544

Corse-Scott, John & Colleen D

John Corse-Scott (PDF, 365 KB)

 

0874

Davidson, Bruce N

Bruce Davidson (PDF, 324 KB)

SAGE Report

Southern Sector Growth Report

0559

Elliot, Julie

 

Bio Initiative Report

1251

Forbes-Brown, Steve & Melissa

Steve Forbes-Brown (PDF, 20 KB)

 

1048

Franklin District Council

Mayor Mark Ball (PDF, 205 KB)

Franklin District Council Growth Strategy

1070

Glencoal Energy Ltd & The Stirlings

Benjamin Coleman (PDF, 415 KB)

Julie Stirling (PDF, 1010 KB)

Ian Brown (PDF, 12 KB)

Coalfields plan

Maramaraua Coalfiled plan

Glencoals Interests

Maxwell Block titles

Stirling Block Titles

Location of Maxwell and Stirling blocks

Line and towers location Maxwell block

Glencoals submission

Aerial photo with designation

Figure Maxwell Block unconstrained

Figure Maxwell Block constrained

Cross section subsurface geology

1014 Hancock forest Management (NZ) Ltd's Sally Strang (PDF, 921  KB)  

1047

Housing New Zealand Corporation

Christine Chong (PDF, 1080 KB)

Housing New Zealand property locations

0748

Hunua & Paparimu Valley Residents Association

Doug Parker (PDF, 132 KB)

Updated evidence

Submission

Khot evidence review

Steven evidence review

Noble evidence review

Lister evidence review

Colley evidence review

Wildash evidence review

Images referenced in evidence review

0337

Hyland, Paul

Paul Hyland (PDF, 67 KB)

 

0813

Jefferis, Stuart G

Stu Jefferis (PDF, 441 KB)

 
1197 Jones, Alison Anne Alison Jones (PDF, 33 KB)  

0498

Kilfoyle, Allanah

Allanah Kilfoyle (PDF, 333 KB)

Paper on childhood cancer (Wales)

Paper on childhood cancer (Sweden)

Residential exposure to powerlines

Paper on childhood leukemia(2)

Pooled analysis of power lines and childhood leukaemia

0914

Levesque, Lance R & Donna M

Lance and Donna Levesque (PDF, 395 KB)


Updated evidence

Cabinet paper

Bio Initiative Report

Emails on cable technology

Transpower Report - Effect of short cable sections on reliability of a 400kV overhead line

Transpower response to Electricity Commission request for information

0556

Mackay, Ewan J

Roger Loveless (PDF, 1015 KB)

Aerial View Maps

0781

Makin, John L & Marilyn R

John Makin (PDF, 1850 KB)

Route plan

News article

Route plan

Image

Image

Large scale route map

EMF article

ICNIRP Guidelines

Sage report extract

ESR article

Energy solutions

Article Conductors

Article Cables

Article cable usage

Article transmission technology

Article Superconductors history

Article Superconductors

Article Superconducting lines

Article Superpower wire

Article Superconductor cables

Article Global energy

Article Supercable

Article Supergrid

Article Nuclear power plants

Article Cleaner coal plants

Article Coal gasification

Article Role of lignites

Article More nuclear power

Article Nuclear britain

Article Australia nuclear review

Article New nuclear reactors

Article Nuclear fusion power

Article Nuclear fusion options

Article Plasma physics

0861

Manukau City Council

Christopher Freke (PDF, 2470 KB)

Neil Hegley (PDF, 225 KB)

Clayton McKenzie (PDF, 1160 KB)

Dennis J. Scott (PDF, 411 KB)

Jade Wikaira (PDF, 872 KB)

Updated evidence

Rural area map

Route map

Flatbush aerial

Aerial overlay

Flatbush topography

Floodplain

1113

Matamata Piako District Council

Bridget Gilbert (PDF, 138 KB)

Michael O’Connor (PDF, 36 KB)

Gary Orbell (PDF, 35 KB)

Daniel Phillips (PDF, 2170 KB)

Marius Rademeyer (PDF, 68 KB)

Landscape

Location maps

Visual aspects

Route Land Parcels

Town and Route Map

Growth Boundaries

1077

Maungatautari Ecological Island Trust

James Mylchreest (PDF, 21 KB)

DoC Status

Parks History

0783

McAlley, Barry N

Barry and Barbara Mc.Alley (PDF, 33 KB)

Ian McAlley (PDF, 170 KB)

 

0361

McCready, Candace

Candace McCready (PDF, 137 KB)

 
0358 McCready, Gillian Gillian McCready (PDF, 137 KB)  
0360 McCready, James James McCready (PDF, 137 KB)  
0360 McCready, Stuart Stuart McCready (PDF, 137 KB)  
0286 McCready, William Evans William McCready (PDF, 137 KB)  
0386 McCready, William Havelock William H McCready (PDF, 137 KB)  
1008 McKenzie, Randal & Melanie Randal McKenzie and Mark Spring (PDF, 438 KB)  

1076

McQueen, Robert

Robert McQueen (PDF, 23 KB)

Health standard final

Article Limiscarriage

Article Draperbmj

Article Connecticut

Editorial

Article Lowenthal 07

Article Henshaw

Article Winterfeldt

Report Martuzzi

Article Milham

Article O’Carrol EMF

Article Beale

Appendix 1 - Waikato Hydro Consents

Karapiro Crossing

Arapuni Crossing

Whakamaru Crossing

Taupo District Council Plan – Noise Standards

1041

Mighty River Power Ltd

Timothy Densem (PDF, 1730 KB)

 

0409

Milne, Grant Stewart Ellis

Grant Milne (PDF, 20 KB)

 

1095

Ministry of Economic Development

Robin Wilson (PDF, 48 KB)

 

0823

Ministry of Health

Martin Gledhill (PDF, 434 KB)

EMF Guidelines

Emails

Submission Point

Suggested Advice
1096 New Zealand Council for Infrastructure Development Stephen Selwood (PDF, 453 KB)  

0992

New Zealand Historic Places Trust

Sherry Reynolds (PDF, 520 KB)

 

0558

Parrish, Murray

Murray Parrish (PDF, 954 KB)

Transpower Letter
0988 Peart, Bruce J & Frances J Robert Merlo (PDF, 364 KB) Photos and Images

0737

Polley, Helen P

Helen Polley (PDF, 7 KB)

 

1159

Pronger, David & Barbara

David and Barbara Pronger (PDF, 47 KB)

 

0765

Regis Park Stage 2 Ltd

Mark Mason (PDF, 535 KB)

 

0718

Rennie, John S & Annie E

John and Annie Rennie (PDF, 29 KB)

 

0643

Robinson, Dr Paul

Paul Robinson (PDF, 6340 KB)

Profile Span

Land Areas

0380

Scott, Dennis John

Dennis Scott (PDF, 48 KB)

 
1184 Scott, John Edward John Scott (PDF, 76 KB)  

0771

Self, John O & Adriana M

John Self (PDF, 285 KB)

 
0799 South Waikato District Council

Aaron Collier (PDF, 136 KB)

Di Lucas (PDF, 168 KB)

Updated evidence

 

Photos

0739

Spring, Mark & Rachel

Randal McKenzie and Mark Spring (PDF, 438 KB)

 

0095

Stewart, Beverley F

Beverley Stewart (PDF, 18 KB)

 

1161

Te Hoe Holdings Ltd

Te Hoe Holdings Ltd (PDF, 44 KB)

 

1244

Underground in Manukau

Catherine Tuck (PDF, 65 KB)

Updated evidence

Submission 1

Submission 2

Submission 3

Submission 4

Submission 5

Submission 6

Ardmore risk

Cost of underground release

Cost of underground calculations

Conference may 07

Craven air space

Electricity Commission letter June 05

Explosion

Gasgoigne

Parker letter Oct 05

Pylon comparison

Pylon comparison pictures

0863

Vector Ltd

Timothy Chatterton (PDF, 2310 KB)

David Robinson (PDF, 835 KB)

Peter Sacree (PDF, 1150 KB)

 

1129

Vercoe, George WH

George Vercoe (PDF, 159 KB)

Plans

1200

Waikato District Council

Dynes Fulton (PDF, 1220 KB)

Alasdair Gray (PDF, 602 KB)

Letter

Access Management Agreement

1088

Waikato Raupatu Trustee Company Ltd

Julian Williams (PDF, 56 KB)

 

0984

Waipa District Council

Mary Buckland (PDF, 5420 KB)

Peter Hassall (PDF, 1120 KB)

David Mansergh (PDF, 101 KB)

John Olliver (PDF, 4290 KB)

Appendix 1 - District Plan Policy and Objectives

Appendix 1 - Regional Policy Statement Aspects

Waipa District Plan – special landscape character areas

Comparison of W&E route evaluations

Graphical Material – Mansergh

Illustrations - Buckland

 

Last updated: 26 March 2010